|
“U.S. society
is extremely naive
about the nature
of agricultural
production.
“[I]f the
public knew more
about the way
in which agricultural
and animal production
infringes on animal
welfare, the outcry
would be louder.”
Bernard
E. Rollin, PhD
Farm Animal
Welfare
Iowa State
U. Press, 2003 |
|
|
|
Many people believe that animals
raised for food must be treated
well because sick or dead animals
would be of no use to agribusiness.
This is not true.
The competition to produce inexpensive
meat, eggs, and dairy products has
led animal agribusiness to treat
animals as objects and commodities.
The worldwide trend is to replace
small family farms with “factory
farms”—large warehouses
where animals are confined in crowded
cages or pens or in restrictive
stalls.1
Bernard Rollin, PhD, explains that
it is “more economically efficient
to put a greater number of birds
into each cage, accepting lower
productivity per bird but greater
productivity per cage…individual
animals may ‘produce,’
for example gain weight, in part
because they are immobile, yet suffer
because of the inability to move…Chickens
are cheap, cages are expensive.”2
In an article recommending space
be reduced from 8 to 6 square feet
per pig, industry journal National
Hog Farmer suggests that “Crowding
pigs pays.”3
See also: video;
Meet
Your Meat (order).
Birds
|
“In
my opinion,
if most
urban meat
eaters were
to visit
an industrial
broiler
house, to
see how
the birds
are raised,
and could
see the
birds being
‘harvested’
and then
being ‘processed’
in a poultry
processing
plant, they
would not
be impressed
and some,
perhaps
many of
them would
swear off
eating chicken
and perhaps
all meat.”
Peter
Cheeke,
PhD
Contemporary
Issues in
Animal Agriculture
2004
textbook |
|
|
|
In the United States, virtually
all birds raised for food are factory
farmed.4
Inside the densely populated buildings,
where they are confined their entire
lives, enormous amounts of waste
accumulate. The resulting ammonia
levels commonly cause painful burns
to the birds' skin, eyes, and respiratory
tracts.5
As reported in “Settling
Doubts About Livestock Stress,”
published in the March 2005 issue
of Agricultural Research
magazine (USDA ARS), "Farmers
trim from a third to a half of the
beaks off chickens, turkeys, and
ducks to cut losses from poultry
pecking each other." This causes
severe pain for several weeks.8
Some, unable to eat after being
debeaked, starve.2
See also: “Enter
the Chicken Shed” (PDF);
ducks;
the
life of a broiler; the
turkey industry (2006); photos;
more
photos.
Egg-Laying Hens
Packed in wire cages (the industry
average is less than half a square
foot of floor space per bird),6
hens can become immobilized and
die of asphyxiation or dehydration.
Decomposing corpses are found in
cages with live birds. Tens of millions
(approximately 14%) of egg-laying
hens die during production each
year.6,7
Those who survive are removed from
the farms when deemed no longer
economically viable. Some of these
“spent hens” (the industry
term for layers who have completed
their egg production cycles) are
sold for slaughter; the rest are
rendered, composted, or destroyed
by other means (e.g., on two California
farms, workers fed 30,000 live
hens into wood chippers). By
the time spent hens are removed
for low production, their skeletons
are so fragile that many suffer
broken bones during catching, transport,
or shackling.36
Male chicks, of no economic value
to the egg industry, are typically
gassed2
or macerated (ground up alive).9
Maceration is becoming a
common method for disposing
of male chicks.
See also: “Act
of God”; Ban
Battery Cages; Egg
Industry; Search
for Humane Eggs; more
photos.
Pigs
|
The Food Marketing
Institute’s
(FMI) Animal Welfare
Program guidelines
do not require
that a sow (mother
pig) have enough
room to walk or
turn around, but
rather that she
actually has enough
room to fit in
the cage without
being forced against
the bars.31
Some in the pig
industry believe
that these regulations
that don't allow
for walking or
turning are something
to be proud of:
“Hog
producers should
toot own horn.” |
|
|
|
In the September 1976 issue of
the industry journal Hog Farm
Management, John Byrnes advised:
“Forget the pig is an animal.
Treat him just like a machine in
a factory.”
Today’s pig farmers
have done just that. As Morley Safer
related on 60
Minutes: “This [motion
picture Babe] is the way
Americans want to think of pigs.
Real-life ‘Babes’ see
no sun in their limited lives, with
no hay to lie on, no mud to roll
in. The sows live in tiny cages,
so narrow they can’t even
turn around. They live over metal
grates, and their waste is pushed
through slats beneath them and flushed
into huge pits.”
On September 17, 208, the Associated
Press reported
on a cruelty investigation performed
by PeTA at a pig farm in Iowa. The
report stated in part:
“The video, shot by People
for the Ethical Treatment of Animals,
shows farm workers hitting sows
with metal rods, slamming piglets
on a concrete floor and bragging
about jamming rods into sows'
hindquarters....
“At one point in the video,
workers are shown slamming piglets
on the ground, a practice designed
to instantly kill those baby pigs
that aren't healthy enough. But
on the video, the piglets are
not killed instantly, and in a
bloodied pile, some piglets can
be seen wiggling vainly. The video
also shows piglets being castrated,
and having their tails cut off,
without anesthesia.
See also: “When
Pigs Cry”; investigation;
more
photos.
Dairy Cows
From 1940 to 2004, average per-cow
milk production rose from 2.3 to
9.5 tons per year;7
some cows have surpassed 30 tons.9
High milk production often causes
udder breakdown, leading to early
slaughter.1
It is unprofitable to keep cows
alive once their milk production
declines. They are usually killed
at 5 to 6 years of age,1
though their normal life span exceeds
20.
Dairy cows are rarely allowed to
nurse their young.1
Many male calves are slaughtered
immediately, while others are raised
for “special-fed veal”kept
in individual stalls and chained
by the neck on a 23 foot tether
for 18 to 20 weeks before being
slaughtered.9
See also: How
does drinking milk hurt cows?;
Tour
a Dairy Farm; and this Q&A
explaining the fate of cows on an
organic dairy farm.
Free-Range Farms
A growing number of people are
looking to free-range products as
an alternative to factory-farmed
animal products. Poultry meat may
be labeled “free-range”
if the birds were provided an
opportunity to access the outdoors.
No other requirementssuch
as the stocking density, the amount
of time spent outdoors, or the quality
and size of the outdoor areaare
specified by the USDA.37
As a result, free-range conditions
may amount to 20,000 birds crowded
inside a shed with a single exit
leading to a muddy strip, saturated
with droppings.
The free-range label applies only
to birds raised for meat, not eggs.
There is a cage-free label for eggs;
but it is not regulated by the USDA,
nor does it guarantee that the hens
were provided access to the outdoors.
Neither label requires third-party
certification. Even for USDA Organic,
the most extensively regulated label,
minimum levels of outdoor access
have not been set and specific rules
do not apply to stocking density
or flock size.37
Male chicks, of no value to the
egg industry, are killed at birth;
and female chicks, whether destined
for cages or not, are typically
debeaked at the hatchery. Although
hens can live more than 10 years,
they’re killed after a year
or two.
Free-range and cage-free farms
vary greatly, and while they may
be an improvement over conventional
farms, they are by no means free
of suffering. Visiting the farms
and slaughterhouses is the only
way to know how the animals are
being raised and killed before the
meat hits your plate.
For more information, see this
page.
|
“To visit a modern
CAFO (Confined Animal
Feeding Operation) is
to enter a world that,
for all its technological
sophistication, is still
designed according to
Cartesian principles:
animals are machines
incapable of feeling
pain. Since no thinking
person can possibly
believe this any more,
industrial animal agriculture
depends on a suspension
of disbelief on the
part of the people who
operate it and a willingness
to avert your eyes on
the part of everyone
else.
“From everything
I’ve read, egg
and hog operations are
the worst. Beef cattle
in America at least
still live outdoors,
albeit standing ankle
deep in their own waste
eating a diet that makes
them sick. And broiler
chickens…at least
don’t spend their
eight-week lives in
cages too small to ever
stretch a wing. That
fate is reserved for
the American laying
hen, who passes
her brief span piled
together with a half-dozen
other hens in a wire
cage whose floor a single
page of this [New
York Times] magazine
could carpet. Every
natural instinct of
this animal is thwarted,
leading to a
range of behavioral
‘vices’
that can include cannibalizing
her cagemates and rubbing
her body against the
wire mesh until it is
featherless and bleeding.…
[T]he 10 percent or
so of hens that can’t
bear it and simply die
is built into the cost
of production. And when
the output of the others
begins to ebb, the hens
will be ‘force-molted’starved
of food and water and
light for several days
in order to stimulate
a final bout of egg
laying before their
life’s work is
done.…
|
|
| Many
breeding sows
spend their
adult lives
in gestation
and farrowing
stalls where
they cannot
turn around
(click
for larger
image;
courtesy of
PETA). |
|
“Piglets in confinement
operations are weaned
from their mothers 10
days after birth (compared
with 13 weeks in nature)
because they gain weight
faster on their hormone-
and antibiotic-fortified
feed. This premature
weaning leaves the pigs
with a lifelong craving
to suck and chew, a
desire they gratify
in confinement by biting
the tail of the animal
in front of them. A
normal pig would fight
off his molester, but
a demoralized pig has
stopped caring. ‘Learned
helplessness’
is the psychological
term, and it’s
not uncommon in confinement
operations, where tens
of thousands of hogs
spend their entire lives
ignorant of sunshine
or earth or straw, crowded
together beneath a metal
roof upon metal slats
suspended over a manure
pit. So it’s not
surprising that an animal
as sensitive and intelligent
as a pig would get depressed,
and a depressed pig
will allow his tail
to be chewed on to the
point of infection.
Sick pigs, being underperforming
‘production units,’
are clubbed to death
on the spot. The USDA’s
recommended solution
to the problem is called
‘tail docking.’
Using a pair of pliers
(and no anesthetic),
most but not all of
the tail is snipped
off. Why the little
stump? Because the whole
point of the exercise
is not to remove the
object of tail-biting
so much as to render
it more sensitive.
Now, a bite on the tail
is so painful that even
the most demoralized
pig will mount a struggle
to avoid it.…
“More than any
other institution, the
American industrial
animal farm offers a
nightmarish glimpse
of what capitalism can
look like in the absence
of moral or regulatory
constraint. Here in
these places life itself
is redefinedas
protein productionand
with it suffering. That
venerable word becomes
‘stress,’
an economic problem
in search of a cost-effective
solution, like tail-docking
or beak-clipping or,
in the industry’s
latest plan, by simply
engineering the ‘stress
gene’ out of pigs
and chickens. Our own
worst nightmare such
a place may well be;
it is also real life
for the billions of
animals unlucky enough
to have been born beneath
these grim steel roofs,
into the brief, pitiless
life of a ‘production
unit’ in the days
before the suffering
gene was found.”
Michael
Pollan, “An Animal’s
Place,” The
New York Times Magazine,
11/10/02 |
|
Transport
& Stockyards  |